Joto's Pizza - Seminole - Seminole, Florida

Meh H.

I typically enjoy ordering pizza, Jotos fingers, and Greek salad from this place. However, I decided to try something new and ordered a chicken salad for $10.52. I was taken aback when it arrived—what I received was essentially a side salad! I think I’ll just return to the Greek salad next time.

Jeff M. D.

This was recommended by a fellow elite yelper on Thursday and I felt compelled to do a carry out of two small pizzas to see what the hype was about. Yes it was all hype to me.

I will say the woman on the phone and staff were very friendly and the interior looked like a fun place to have a meal and some beers. That’s all on the positive.

I love Chicago style pizza (both Tavern Style and Deep Dish) also Brooklyn style with the occasional Neapolitan za but this was what I like to call Frozen Pizza meets Ballpark Pizza. It was that bad. The crust was bland, the sausage was small and the veggies were diced as opposed to pseudo large pieces.

If people like this kind of mediocre pizza due to non exposure of quality pizza, all good but I’ll do a hard pass.

Jessica C.

We love to go to Joto’s! Our favorite and go to every time we visit there, is we always have to get their Joto’s Fingers. Kinda like garlic knots but these are strips, and they are served in a bowl with the perfect amount of garlic butter sauce. Delicious! A must have as an appetizer before your meal. We also enjoy their cheese pizza. The crust is not hard like most places. It’s the perfect dinner out on the town! Highly recommend!

Alyssa H.

A typical pizza shop. The pizza was good but it wasn’t anything super special. They do make gluten free pizza which was nice. The service was nice and everyone was friendly. The bathrooms were decent but could be better. They did accommodate a large group of us on very short notice which was pretty awesome! Parking was difficult as there wasn’t much. Overall not a bad experience.

Dan G. J.

Always delicious. Never had a bad experience.

Joshua

Very friendly service and excellent pizza at a fair price. $27ish dollars bought bread sticks (Joto fingers), water to drink, and an extra large cheese pizza. This feed all four of us. The atmosphere was very reminiscent of the 90s. I would recommend a meal here if you are in the area and are craving pizza.

Stephen C.

It's exactly what you would expect from a place that is celebrating their 50th year. Comfortable seats and friendly wait staff. The best part for us is this - if you want your pizza on the thicker side, they will oblige...if you want it on the thinner side, they will stretch it further! Well done is our recommendation, and they will be happy to accommodate that as well!

I wish we had discovered it sooner. We live on Treasure Island, and it is worth the drive. Here's to another 50 years!

T M.

We ordered online, received the wrong item, and the "manager" refused to send us our correct order. She actually claimed she had to guess which one we purchased (as if the price didn't give it away) and then admitted to guessing wrong but refused to make it right. ‍ The food is mediocre (think gas station pizza) and the manager is even less than that.