The Cookie Cottage, LLC - Mapleton, Utah

Joys P.

Everything here is AMAZING!!!!! I was fortunate to catch the owner while in the lobby- definitely call ahead for hours, or better yet, place an order ahead of time.
She has a magic power of making cookies soft and chewy on the inside, but crisp on the outside. They're unbelievable.
We talked about her business, and she's 1000% committed to quality ingredients, hand making each dessert, and providing a personal touch.
I'm a customer for life!

Kelsie B.

I don’t know how she does it! Samantha is not only a wonderful and delightful person to be around but Every. Single. Treat she bakes is just incredible! Her sweet potato cookies sounded just too strange but one bite and oh man, they are just out of this world! We went there for treats for my sons birthday and we needed a gluten and even egg free option... done! And it was delicious! The cupcakes, cookies, healthy, etc etc all worth it! Beautiful, best you’ll ever taste and such a fun and personal experience everytime you go! I just love it there!

John W.

We just went to the Cookie Cottage today and it is an absolutely adorable little dessert bakery. We went right at the end of the day and there was still a variety of options we could choose from. Samantha, the owner, is absolutely wonderful. She walked us through all the options and gave suggestions. We got two Boston cream puffs (absolutely phenomenal), a lemon raspberry cupcake, a peaches and cream cookie, a lavender and white chocolate scone, a frosted sweet potato cake, and pineapple watermelon granola bites. They were all absolutely delicious and enjoyed each bite. The cream puffs were our favorite by far but everything was so good. There was plenty more we didn’t get that we will 100% be back soon to try. You should absolutely go try out this adorable bakery.

Kayla L.

Samantha the owner is delightful! My cousin and I went right at closing time and pretty much everything was gone. She gave us samples of her gluten free fig bars and I honestly didn't have high hopes because I like gluten and I'm not usually a fan of fig. Well they were pleasantly delicious! I like to be proven wrong.
I also went a few months ago and got a bunch of different treats that were all really yummy. I love supporting small, local businesses and this one definitely deserves your support.

Natalie A.

I haven’t liked any of the new cookie bakeries popping up all along the Wasatch front. They just taste like fake sugary emptiness. This one is different! It tasted rich and filling. It’s not over the top sweet, but so satisfying!!! The owner was there and she was so engaging and authentic! I loved the service and the sweets.!!

Kceedilla

Amazing!! I have a chocolate allergy and there are so many options that I eat! Wide variety of items!

Josh J.

I'm a big fan of cookies. Cookies hold a special place in my heart - I don't know what it is about them, but a good cookie just feels like home. I've tried a lot of different cookies from a lot of different places, homemade, store-bought, you name it. The chocolate chip cookies Sam makes here are, bar none, the best cookies I've ever had. They taste like they were made by someone who think about cookies all day, every day. They taste like passion for a craft that elevates it to an art. They taste like the recipe took 30 years to perfect.

Also? They're like $2! They're cheaper than a Maverick cookies (those are $2.19; I checked.) They cost less than half of a Crumbl cookie once you take delivery fees and tip into account. I'm trying to convince the owner to raise her prices (I've lived on the west coast - people would pay $6 for a cookie this good and post it on Instagram), but she won't budge. I think you should stop by before she changes her mind. I'd happily fork over a boutique price for excellence, but when you get something this special for less than you'd pay at a franchise, you've found yourself a local treasure.

And to the guy who got extra stuff for free and then had the *audacity* to complain about value: I don't know what to tell you? Maybe you'd like the cookies better if they were smothered in Cisco-brand food-service cake frosting, topped with a few Oreos, and served in a bucket. Or if they charged you some extra fees that aren't on the menu. But then again, maybe you'd like them more if they cost what they were worth - you can't put a price tag on taste! In the meantime, I consider myself blessed to live within walking distance of this particular baking establishment. Long live The Cookie Cottage!

Corinne B.

Cookie Cottage deserves every inch of their 5 stars!! From the moment I walked in I could feel the energy dial turn up on my day. Their customer service not just to me but to those around me was heads and shoulders above your typical small business. When I mentioned that I was about to go on my first date after my divorce those ladies left me feeling like a million bucks! And I got cookies! How is this not a part of your day It should be. Who doesn't need Cookie Cottage in their life