Mazzio's Italian Eatery - Bentonville, Arkansas

Jaye P.

Best cauliflower crust pizza in Bentonville but dont ever order delivery.

Pictures are how i recieved my delivered order. Ive ordered from a multitude of pizza places since i can remember and ive never gotten a pile of garbage before til Mazzios.

I do not recommend.

Brian C

Went in at lunch time. Cashier was very friendly when she took our order. Ordered one buffet and one ham and cheese sandwich. Salad bar was low or out of various items. Pizza on the buffet was not being replenished quickly and what was there, had been there a while. One customer cleared her own table and went behind the counter and got cleaning supplies to clean her own table.
I had finished my food and my wife's sandwich has still not come out. This has been over 30 minutes.
I walked to the counter and could see them working on it, so I waited. As the person making the sandwich finished, the cashier said " that is his sandwich". When the lady handed it to me, I said this took over 30 minutes". I then started to walk back to my table and the cashier yelled " I'm sorry, you can see we are busy, do you want a refund? You can see we are slammed. I had 2 people call in" I walked back over in a low voice and said, " I would like you to lower your voice. I merely told you it took over 30 minutes, you do not need to yell for the whole freaking restaurant to hear." I then walked to my table. The cashier then yelled she needed a smoke break. When other customers came in she told them that customers had been yelling at her.
I totally get being busy, but this was not handled well. The cashier was already frazzled by the customer that kept going behind the counter to put up plates and get cleaning supplies. I will not be back.

Brooke D.

You sent out a pizza with DoorDash that was hardly cooked. It was heavy as hell like 15 toppings were on it. Smeared with sauce, cheese and pepperoni. Definitely not DoorDash issue but yet that’s who I’m to call. It’s a total mess from not being cooked and all the toppings slid over the crust on the other side of the pizza.

Grisel H

We were in town for my 2yr olds birthday. Pizza is one of her favorite things to eat. We were wanting buffet but it wasn't offered on Saturdays. No big deal. I had 3 teenagers and my husband. The girl at the register was going over some family specials they had going on. We were putting our order in and a couple had walked in. We were adding some extra items and finalizing our order. The couple walked out. At the next register there was an elderly female employee. She has been there in that area pretty much the whole time. The couple had left without ordering. She said " Great now we lost some customers ". The young lady helping us started apologizing to her. She said " oh I know it's not your fault". I paid. While I was handlng everyone their drink cups the elderly employee mentioned again that the couple had left. Another employee told her it was because buffet wasn't being offered.The way it was said made me feel like it was my fault for putting in a big order. We go get our drinks and the restaurant had NO ICE!!. I had already paid and everyone was hungry. Otherwise we would've left. It would've been nice if that was mentioned before ordering.We Sat at the back of the restaurant drinking our warm soda while waiting on food. Once it finally came out the pizza was very greasy. The rest of the order was ok. While we're eating we could hear the elderly lady cussing non stop. We don't care if people cuss, because we do too. But the way she was doing it was definitely uncalled for in my opinion for a family restaurant. The young lady that took our was very nice though. We definitely won't be going back.

Michelle L

Family of 3 went at 5 pm. There was no ranch dressing on the salad bar.. waited for that.... No ice in the machine. That never was fixed. Windows beside us covered in greasy hand prints. It was all just ugh.
As a fun bonus the restaurant was really smoky, I assume from something that had burned.

Devon Arredondo

Mazzio's has a special place in the corner of my nostalgic Oklahoman teenage years. I remember cinnamon sticks dripped with melted butter and a buffet filled with some of the best (and greasiest) thin crust around. Unfortunately, as an adult, this just ain't that place anymore. The place felt dingy, dirty and disappointing. I went for the lunch buffet on a random Tuesday. There was barely any pizza out and the cinnamon sticks (When finally replenished) were severely undercooked. At some point, you get what you pay for. This just isn't worth it.

Tam Tam

I've never had issues with the buffet, delivery or carryout. I actually enjoy this pizza and it's fresh. Definitely no complaints but if they decide to start acting up after I leave this nice review then ya will be the first to know!!

Dustin H

All I can say is WOW, what a pleasant surprise. Don't judge a book by it's cover, these guys can make some good pizza. I was skeptical because I had never been, but my wife convinced me to try them. A little pricey but what isn't these days. Everything tasted fresh, the dough was perfectly cooked, and we will be back many more times I'm sure.