Arizona Pizza Company Surprise - Surprise, Arizona

Lee N. D. A.

I’d give a 3.5. I normally don’t review but said I would. It’s a friendly local joint that I saw gives to the community and was recommended so gave it a try. It was good but probably would not order again.

Appearance 4 - looks beautiful, good amount of toppings
Taste 3 - average pizza, sauce is pasty, toppings seemed fresh, crust was the best part. Zucchini mushy, don’t recommend. Mozzarella sticks too thick and hard, not gooey.
Cost 3 - $70 for a couple pizzas and sides, about the same as others that I’ve had better at. Was delivered by Uber so had to pay fees.

Mori

Ordered here for the first time and they completely messed up on our pizza order. As posted in the receipt it shows that the two pizzas both had 3 toppings each, but they decided to put most of the toppings on the one thin crust pizza and didn't even have all the toppings on the list as well, it was missing both pineapple and jalapenos and our regular crust pizza was just cheese. It wasn't even worth our time to complain about it since we were all super hungry and didn't want to deal with the wait and hassle, which was a tough pill to swallow since the pizzas were $20.25 each. Aside from the massive mess up, the thin crust pizza was definitely the way to go since the regular crust was too doughy.
The wings were decent, not worth $15.99 for 10 though and the mozzarella sticks were fine and also not worth the sticker price of $11.99

Not sure we would order from here for delivery again, but there may be a slim chance we would order for pick up (just pizzas) if we see one along our route, but won't go out of our way.

Incognito J.

Wow!! I agree with the other review that this is a great way to turn an order that would normally be thrown out, in to a blessing ! The presentation of the pizza was a perfect 10/10 classic pepperoni , the crust was my favorite bubbly , and soft! Thank you for the blessing ! Food tasted good and I will return for sure as a paying customer ! Yall were closing but I’d love to try some other menus items for sure next time !

shortcake210382

My son and I went this evening at closing and we got a pepperoni pizza. It was so good. The crust was fluffy but had a good crunch. The sauce was good the cheese was good
It was honestly the best pizza I’ve had in a very long time. I had already eaten a lice before taking this picture. When I got home my 8 year old said “where did you get this pizza, this is the best pizza ever “

Ingrid M.

Received a pepperoni pizza and it's so good! Reminds me of a place I used to go to during my childhood. You know a good pizza when it brings back fond memories. The staff is amazing and friendly! I asked for light sauce too, I appreciate the accommodation! Definitely will come back often to try more of the menu! Thank you!

Sam H.

5-Star Local Gem Alert!
Just had the BEST surprise treat from Arizona Pizza Company in Surprise, AZ — and it came with a side of heartwarming community love! The owner, Karissa, is a former nurse turned rockstar entrepreneur who took an unclaimed order and gave it away for free to the community rather than let it go to waste. That’s not just smart — that’s service with soul!
The pizza? A large thin crust loaded with mushrooms, bell peppers, olives, and red onion — and yes, it was still warm when we got it! Flavorful without being greasy, perfectly balanced, and satisfying without the guilt. My daughter and I devoured it together, and she declared it five-star service (and I totally agree).

Karissa , was an absolute doll face — warm, friendly, and clearly passionate about both people and pizza. Support this place, y’all. It’s not just about great food; it’s about great people doing great things!

Tiffany H.

They posted about 2 free Pizzas that they were giving away to first come first serve. I happened to have just got on FB right as it was posted and made it in time to try the White Pizza. Klarice (spelling) the owner was there and introduced herself, very sweet and thankful for us trying their pizza! The Pizza was Amazing!!! Our first time trying it and there was not a slice left!!! The white sauce is amazing, pizza dough and crust, didn’t even need ranch with it, it was that good!!! We will be back to try more!!!

Tyler W.

Arizona Pizza Company never disappoints! The food is always fresh, flavorful, and served hot. The crust has the perfect crunch, the toppings are generous, and the menu has something for everyone—from classic pepperoni to creative specialty pies.

The staff is friendly, welcoming, and attentive, whether you're dining in or picking up. It's clear they care about quality and customer satisfaction. The atmosphere is relaxed and inviting—perfect for a casual meal with friends or family.

If you're looking for great pizza and a consistently awesome experience, Arizona Pizza Company is the spot. Highly recommend!